Comelia Walker washed out in her bid to overturn the results of the Canton Mayoral Democratic primary election held on April 22. Walker lost to Canton Ealdorman Tim Taylor by 43 votes and challenged the election in Madison County Circuit Court.
Ms. Walker claimed voters were disenfranchised in the Trails of Madison apartments, Kingston Subdivision, and the Westside Trailer Park. The petition alleged Canton annexed these areas in 2020 but failed to enter them in the Statewide Election Management System (SEMS). The city allegedly did not update the voter rolls and the Canton Democratic Party Executive Committee did not correct the discrepancy.
The losing candidate argues the number of people affected was greater than the margin of victory.
Ms. Walker claimed there were 221 registered voters at the Trails, 500 voters in Kingston, and 100 voters in Westside.All Madison County Circuit judges recused themselves from the case. It was assigned to Special Guest Star Judge Jeff Weill. Judge Weill heard it all in a trial lasting several days. Judge Weill said it was clear "not one voter was denied the right to vote or was disenfranchised in any way." Circuit Judge Dewey Arthur denied a similar petition several weeks earlier. Judge Arthur held it was too late to enter the addresses in SEMS since that petition was filed the day before the election. However, the learned jurist ordered the city of Canton to provide affidavit ballots to any residents of the disputed areas who showed up to vote. Earlier post. The Court held Ms. Walker provided little, if any evidence to support her claims:
The Petitioner failed to prove the number of voters in the annexed area 15 whose status was not updated in SEMS and argues without basis - only speculation - that virtually all were not included on the poll books. That is not the case. The circuit clerk stated she and the current Canton city clerk had for more than a year, through a slow and frustrating process, added many,many of the annexed voters to SEMS and they were included in the poll books. No witness came forward to say otherwise. Thus, the argument that a vast number of annexed voters were excluded from the poll books, creating was a massive departure from accepted voting practices was not proven. As for the 11 technical violations, most of which are either minor, such as failing to clean old voting paperwork accumulated in previous elections, or misfiling lists and spoiled ballot envelopes, both the city and circuit clerks testified those instances are common in virtually every election. This was confirmed by the Election Commissioners. The somewhat more serious allegations of affidavit ballots, absentee ballots, and official vote totals not being stored in secure boxes is considerably mitigated by testimony from the city clerk that all of the election paperwork is stored in a vault to which only she has a key. Further, the Petitioner confirms that no fraud or intentionality is alleged. It certainly wasn't proven. It is telling that the Petitioner found zero instances of illegal ballots and made no such challenges which is the common claim in most election cases. The absence of those claims is, in my opinion, relevant proof the election was run properly.
Petitioner admitted, though having been aware of her claims for months, that she and her attorneys were not able to find one person in the annexed area who was either unaware of the election or was denied the right to vote in it.... 18. Ms. Anita Wray, the Circuit Clerk, produced documents subpoenaed by the Petitioner which showed that City Clerk Chuconna Anderson and City Attorney Kimberly Banks had been working with her office for at least one year to provide information so that her office could upload additional streets in the newly annexed areas into SEMS in order to update voters in the annexed areas, change their status to reflect them as municipal voters, and that she had done so many times in the year prior to the election. She noted that after making those status changes in SEMS, her office had mailed out new voter registration cards reflecting that status change to the newly annexed voters. She also testified that adding information into SEMS is a continuous and ongomg process.Ms. Walker was apparently unable to provide any information about the allegedly affected voters:
19. The Petitioner did not offer any evidence of the number of units in the Trails of Madison apartments that were occupied on April 22, 2025, how many registered voters lived there or even the number of registered voters in the entire annexed areas. All such information offered at the hearing was based largely on speculation.
Since the petitioner failed to meet her burden of proving her case, Judge Weill denied the petition.
12 comments:
A candidate suspected a number of errors in the election and filed suit. Those responsible for running the election showed up in court with facts and evidence. The judge ruled the election was run properly, and no eligible voters were disenfranchised.
That's the way it's supposed to work.
So sad.
Sometimes the disenfranchise card doesn't play.
Blackmon's next move... Drip Drip Drip...
If the people of canton want to move forward the next step is voting out Lawrence and Bradford. That entire stunt is shameful. Canton will never rise as long as the Blackmon family treats everyone in that city like their personal piggy bank.
Twerk the Vote!
Did someone mention the name Blackmon? The Blackmon Dynasty has been Master of the Canton Plantation for decades.
As with Bennie T. in District 2, the Blackmons will cede control of Canton and most of north Madison County when they are all pushing up daisies.
I’ll be damned, the Blackmons lost!!! The sky is going to fall. Lord help us. Now, if we can get their hands out of CMU Canton might turn around.
ohh if it could only happen!!! Get the Blackmons' out of CMU! What a glorious day that could be.
@3:15 Amen!! That was a disgrace the way they were put in office.
do they ever turn on the aerators on the shit pond near Canton on I-55! Gag a maggot when you drive by there...
So… No Mayor Blackmon?
Post a Comment