Just when everyone was about to write the obituary for the 2016 New Orleans Saints, the San Diego Chargers happened.
Playing at home, leading by two touchdowns with six minutes to go and possessing the football, the Chargers fumbled the ball and victory away. The Saints, to their credit, took advantage of back-to-back Chargers fumbles for an unlikely 35-34 victory.
Had the Saints lost, they would have entered this bye week as one of only two winless teams in the NFL. As it is, the hapless Cleveland Browns, still paying the price of Johnny Manziel, own the dubious distinction of being the lone 0-4 team.
Two ways to look at these Saints:
• One, Sunday's most unlikely of victories, just prolonged the inevitable. The Saints are a fading shadow of the ball club that won the Super Bowl seven seasons ago. New Orleans ranks No. 32 of 32 teams in points allowed and No. 31 of 32 teams in giving up yards. Offensively, they don't protect Drew Brees well enough, they drop too many of Brees' passes and don't run the ball particularly well. They are a team on life support.
• Two, for all their weaknesses, the Saints are tied for second only two games out of first place in the NFC South. Injuries, particularly in the secondary, have decimated the ball club, but the Saints should get some of those guys back. Keep in mind, the Saints lost by one point to the 3-1 Oakland Raiders and by three points to the New York Giants. The Saints could have beaten the division-leading Falcons, if it were not for a fourth quarter pick-six. Thanks to the victory over the Chargers, there's hope.
•••
Because of their proximity and their history, the Saints remain the NFL team of most Mississippians. Yes, the Dallas Cowboys, especially now with rookie Dak Prescott, and the Giants, with Eli Manning, have much support in the Magnolia State. But the Saints remain Mississippi's most favored NFL team.
Mississippians suffered through those early years when the Saints played football as if they were starring in a Saturday Night Live skit. You know: When they played in old Tulane Stadium. When they had an astronaut for a general manager. When Billy Kilmer was booed like Christians in the old Roman Colosseum and was sacrificed like one, too. When the halftime shows were more entertaining than the games. When they did not have a winning season for their first 20 years of existence.
We were sacked along with Archie Manning. We ached with Deuce McAllister's knees. We endured Hurricanes Camille and Katrina along with the black and gold.
And then we exulted in 2009 when Sean Payton and Drew Brees guided the Saints to the NFL Championship. The Black and Gold were champions at last.
•••
Since that 31-17 victory over the Indianapolis Colts on Jan. 31, 2010, in Miami, the Saints have gone 11-5, 13-3, 7-9, 11-5, 7-9 and 7-9. The trend is not positive. And that brings us to the current 1-3 Saints.
What to make of them?
Drew Brees still plays the game at an extremely high level. Given protection, a semblance of a running game and competent receivers, he's still one of the elite quarterbacks in the sport.
But Brees lacks all that support and the injury-decimated defense, statistically the league's worse, stays on the field far too long.
Complicating matters, Brees makes one of the league's highest salaries, as well he should. The Saints salary cap situation is among the league's worst. Brees' contract, even restructured as it is, does not help in that regard.
It probably should be time to think about starting over, getting what they can for Brees and building for the future. The unlikely victory over San Diego probably delays those discussions, but for how long?
Rick Cleveland is a Jackson-based syndicated columnist. His email address is rcleveland@mississippitoday.org.
Wednesday, October 5, 2016
Rick Cleveland: Is it over for the Saints?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
9 comments:
Regurgitates the already known. Yawn.
This nitwit wants to sell/trade the only really good player on the team. Without Brees the past three seasons, we would be winning 2-3 games per year. Without Brees you can forget about a sold out Dome, or any national attention for the team. They would truly be a joke.
Thank God Cleveland is not the Saints general manager.
Playing Devil's Advocate. The Colts dumped Peyton and got Luck, the Packers got Rogers and dumped Favre.... you get the idea.
Oddly enough, the WSJ had an essay yesterday asking if Romo was about to get Bledsoed.
Saints should have dumped Brees and Payton after last season. Stop delaying the inevitable rebuild. The defense IS a joke.
Doesn't 'want' to sell/trade Brees but asking if it is the best long term strategy. NO has to get some defensive players and needs salary cap flexibility.
I love watching Brees and yes he is the most popular player since Archie. But there are other qbs out there that might not be as good as Brees is/was but would be a hell of a lot cheaper. And yes, NO won't be on top the next year but maybe get back into the competition within the next three.
Luck is carrying the Colts. That organization - starting with that whack-job of an owner - is a dumpster fire.
Been saying Rick's sentiments for a while. Rick is right. 3 7-9 seasons in the last 4 and heading towards 7-9 or worse. They could pay Drew 10 million a year for the next 10 years and he could break every all time passing record, but it's already been shown that none of that matters if they don't cobble together a defense. They are paying him too much for too long. If he's interested in going out a winner, he needs to restructure again. Saints have drafted horribly also, particularly on defense. The shine has worn off '09, it's time for Sean and Mickey to go.
Dump Brees and trade for Dak. He's the best quarterback in the league right now.
Almost everyone here is off their rocker to some degree.
1. Saints don't have a Luck or Rogers waiting in the wings.
2. If you "dump" Brees, you still have the hit on the salary cap.
3. Even if you traded Brees, NOBODY will pay him what the Saints are paying him because they probably can't take the salary cap hit. Even if they did, there are ways to structure the deal so that the Saints still absorb a hit on the cap for him.
4. Prescott is four games into his pro career and you pronounce him "the best in the league." Come back in January after you have sobered up.
5. Agree about terrible defense. Injuries are no excuse for four years of crap.
6. Regarding poor draft selection, that is with the benefit of 20-20 hindsight. Drafting is like reading tea leaves; if you do it right, you are a prophet. If you are wrong, you need to be fired. Sean and Loomis were geniuses when they drafted Colston, Jahri Evans, Roman Harper, Meachem, Jimmy Graham. Now all of a sudden they are draft idiots?? Give me a break.
Post a Comment