In order to fix a problem, you first need to accept that you’ve got a problem. In order for families in our state to get the education their children deserve, we need state leaders to recognize that right now they aren't getting a good enough education.
Instead, what we get is propaganda about the Mississippi education ‘miracle’. The other week the Mississippi Department of Education published the results from the 2023-24 Mississippi Academic Assessment Program (MAAP). Relying on this data to tell you about education in Mississippi would be like leaving it to your child to mark their own homework. Sure enough, having marked their own homework, the Mississippi education bureaucracy told us that “student achievement has reached an all-time high” in math, English and science. Just as you get inflation in the economy, you get grade inflation in the education system. MAAP scores are used to help rate schools and districts A-F. There has been a dramatic fall in the number of D and F rated districts in recent years. This is not because those districts are no longer failing, but because even failing districts get given better grades. A more credible measure of student performance is the national benchmark, the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP). This data tells a less flattering story. • 4 in 10 fourth graders would struggle to read this sentence. In 2022, they could not reach even the basic reading standard. • 82 percent of 8th grade kids in Mississippi were not proficient in math in 2022. • 69 percent of 4th grade kids in Mississippi were not proficient in reading in 2022. Education standards are bad - and they are not getting better! The claim by the Mississippi Department of Education that Mississippi “students have made faster progress than nearly every other state” is ridiculous. The truth is that during the COVID lockdowns, standards as measured by the NAEP plummeted in other states, but barely changed in ours. This meant our relative position rose, but without any significant improvement in outcomes. Officials know all this, yet still present a misleading picture of what has happened in the belief that you will be impressed. Equally implausible is the idea that we should celebrate record high school graduation rates. One in four Mississippi public school students is chronically absent from school. Worse, the number of kids regularly not showing up to school has skyrocketed from 70,275 in 2016-17 to 108,310 in 2022-23. Honesty about the true state of education matters because self-congratulatory propaganda is one reason things don't get fixed. Mississippi has been run by supposed conservatives for over a decade. In all that time, we have seen remarkably little progress towards the kind of big strategic changes we need. In 12 months, Arkansas, Alabama and Louisiana made more progress towards school choice than Mississippi managed in 12 years. Why? A lot of it is down to leadership. Politicians merely looking to progress along the conveyor belt don’t need any vision. They simply aim to “go along to get along”. Mississippi is now surrounded on three sides by states that have universal school choice. In every case, change took courage and vision, not self-congratulation. One of the reasons why Arkansas’ Sarah Huckabee Sanders, Louisiana’s Jeff Landry and Texas’ Greg Abbott are regularly on Fox News and are emerging as conservative leaders with a national profile is because they have shown the tenacity to fight for school choice in their own states. Another part of the problem is that too many have an interest in exaggerating the impact of those reforms that have happened. This may be understandable, but laws passed almost a decade ago are not enough to improve education outcomes today. Our job at MCPP is to push forward conservative policies based on true conservative principles, not dubious press releases. We aim to ensure that conservative leaders in this state finally commit to universal school choice. We are on a mission to ensure that anyone telling you that there has been an education ‘miracle’ looks ridiculous. Only school choice will do.Douglas Carswell is the President and CEO of the Mississippi Center for Public Policy. The Mississippi Center for Public Policy sponsored this post.
27 comments:
So refreshing to hear an unbiased analysis!
The public is being sold a bill of goods about the "improvements"
in pupils attending government schools.
Education isn't that hard. Affluent areas have money. Others do not. Affluent people that live in areas with poor schools pay to send their kids elsewhere. Kids that have reinforcement at home generally do better than kids that do not.
Education starts at home before pre-school. When parents are AWOL at home, and don't read to/with their young children, the kids begin their formal education already behind the curve.
You own the Legislature, Governor and probably the Lt. Governor; since you have all the answers, kindly fix public education.
Or, is it much easier to criticize (even if accurately) than it is to improve a situation?
you must have skipped the last paragraph acknowledging this was a lobbyist's hit piece. Lobbyists only attack when it profits them to do so. At least the author owns what it is. Guess he didn't pay enough to have the comments shut off.
I grew up quite poor in the 80's, but my parents made it clear that I was expected to do well in school. They took us to the small town local library and instilled a love of reading. Our public school education was mid at best, but I graduated college because that was also expected of me.
Lazy, absentee parents that do not want to do the hard work of raising a child is a much bigger problem in our society than our mediocre schools.
Why do we never question the quality of the students? We always look at the teachers, parents, and lack of discipline, but are the majority bright enough to learn?
Yes, affluent areas have more money. But, some of the poorer areas, spend more money per child to educate said child and still don't do a good job whatsoever. Meanwhile, some private schools cost less than many public schools get for educating 1 child, and they tend to do well there. So, what is the solution? We can't make the parents care. Spending more money doesn't necessarily work either. Something needs to be done, I agree. I just don't know what
It should be easy to spot the problem. Is it the teachers? Is it the students? Just two choices.
MCPP has way less influence than they would like you to believe. I don't think anyone with real power takes them seriously.
For 1:55, four problems, third, that should be first, is parents, fourth, which is you for not realizing that fact. Why do you think a teacher could make up for five years of poor parenting prior to kindergarten of first grade?
1:55 you have a valid point. To be a teacher in Mississippi is tough because you know you won't get paid a lot for the results that are expected. Too many districts are also so top heavy with administration that teachers sometimes can't just teach but have to answer to so many above them (what is the ratio of administrators in Jackson Public Schools compared to students?) And what kind of parental participation can be expected when you can barely afford feeding the kids?
don't forget the parents!!
my wife is a teacher for 20 years. we have seen parents that now think the school will do everything for their children. they do not help with homework or even read to or with their kids. we raised three boys by reading to them ever night. checked homework ever night and study with them for test. but parents today are not doing their part of raising their own children.
There has been enough evidence for a long time to prove it is the students. Some people have evolved to build starships and others to chase balls.
It would seem those who work in the dept of education are more concerned with justifying their existence and keeping their high-paying jobs.
3:27 PM, blame the parents if that makes you feel better. That means the students are still the problem. The students are not learning. Why not hold the students back until they learn what the teacher is trying to teach them.
Mississippi spends $6700 per student (HB 4130 implements a BSA of $6,695.34 in FY25). Many others spend up to $20,000 per student.
The MCPP is again identifying a problem and drawing a politically convenient conclusion instead of bothering to take an in depth look at the differences in teaching requirements and curriculum in states with better public schools. Also, horribly ignored are children who are " home schooled". Every child can pass a test if they are taught the answers to the questions repeatedly in the days just before the test. That does not mean they learned or retained anything. Wouldn't we all have loved having a copy of our tests to study the night before being tested much less being taught the answers to the question for days in advance? The PSAT and SAT results would be a far better measure of how prepared our children are. And, even at our private schools, parents need to know how many of those graduates actually successfully get into good colleges and universities and make good grades to pass their freshman and sophomore years.
Try offering to substitute teach for a few days at least before writing an article on the state of education in this state. Also, the notion that " problem" students from "troubled homes" exist only in public schools is ridiculous.
Don't blame schools. Blame politicians who have put these requirements on educators.
Unmotivated students with nasty attitudes prevent others from learning. What ever happened to "Reform Schools"?
Whose fault is it that some parents either can't read or don't read well? You're probably also of the opinion that parents should help their child-scholars with math.
Reform Schools didn't work out. Why? Because it was impossible to 'reform' anybody sent there. Sort of like a 'department of corrections' where nobody is corrected. Shall we discuss a 'rehabilitation program'?
Reform schools do not work. Keeping kids in a grade until they can pass that grade does not work. They used to work. What happened to them?
Funneling public money to the private schools does nothing to solve the problem. It merely gives a break to the leaders of and donors to the MCPP. If MCPP really wants to make a difference, lead the way to seismic change in public education. They have the political clout. The question is, do they really care?
Interesting you left out "Is it the parents?". Was it on purpose? Or out of stupidity?
There won't be any "rehabilitation" if there hasn't ben any HABILITATION in the first place! Pre-kindergarten was Sesame Street, Zoom, and The Electric Company on PBS (before it went communist) and these served millions of children to be fully ready for school. The discipline from parents back then was more than enough to make sure there weren't any distractions or disrespect in the classrooms ever. If there was, that child at hell to pay at home. Now they pathologize them and say, "Poor thing". Nobody wants to discuss the fact that now, more than ever before there are people having children who should not. Period.
Post a Comment