Local mom, Amanda Kibble, is celebrating an important win for her family, and for school choice. Earlier this year, Governor Tate Reeves signed HB 1341 into law. This new law gives military families in Mississippi the right to transfer their children to any traditional public school around the state, assuming that the receiving school has capacity. Early indications suggest this is extremely popular, with lots of military families using school choice to switch schools.
Amanda, and her family, found out the hard way that the law might not apply to those who serve their country in the National Guard. There was a real risk that Amanda’s son might lose his place at his preferred school. That’s when Amanda approached MCPP, and we took up her case. MCPP has a long history of fighting for school choice, and our legal arm, the Mississippi Justice Institute has successfully litigated in defense of school choice. I am delighted that Attorney General, Lynn Fitch, has now issued an opinion that the new school choice law for military families also applies, at least in part, to those in the National Guard. Three cheers for the AG! If military families now have public-to-public school choice, why shouldn’t everybody? That is exactly what our “Move Up, Mississippi!” campaign aims to achieve. This week’s win for school choice makes it all the more disappointing that the new State Superintendent for Education, Lance Evans, took a sideswipe at school choice recently. Speaking at a lunch in Jackson, Evans criticized school choice, suggesting that if a single dollar of public money went into private schools, those private schools should be subjected to the regulatory oversight that public schools are subject to.
Those that oppose school choice, and indeed I suspect Mr. Evans, know full well that extending state oversight across the private school sector would be untenable – which is why they suggest it. But it is not the clever argument against school choice that they might imagine. Giving every family in our state the right to choose a public school, as military families are now able to do, would not transfer public dollars into private schools. Amanda Kibble and those military families that now have school choice are not taking money out of public schools. Does Lance Evans oppose their right to choose a school for their child? MCPP proposes that under a separate program, families that attend private schools, or who home school, could get a tax credit reflecting the fact that they are already paying for a place at a public school that they are not taking. Evans attack on parent power was not the worst of it. More disappointing was the plodding presentation that preceded it about how amazing education is in our state. Evans trumpeted the fact that about a third of districts were rated D or F in 2016. Now only a handful are rated D or F. This, he implied, was evidence of progress, rather than a reflection of a broken accountability system. When officials invoke the broken grading system as evidence of improvement, it is not just the credibility to the grading we should question. How bizarre, that in a solidly Republican-run state, we have somehow ended up with an anti-school choice official in charge? Are the nine-member State Board of Education aware of Evans’ anti-school choice position? Are the various state leaders that appointed those members of the Board? Since 2000, the number of students in America has increased by 5 percent. The number of teachers by around 10 percent. The number of education administrators, however, has shot up by 95 percent. No wonder the education bureaucrats don’t want mom and dad to have control over where their child’s share of the education budget goes. They might start to demand that it goes into the classroom. Lance Evans talked about making private schools accountable. Private schools already are accountable to every fee-paying parent. The issue is how to ensure that public schools are made similarly accountable, too. We need to give every family in our state the public-to-public school choice that military families now have. Douglas Carswell is the President and CEO of the Mississippi Center for Public Policy. Details about school choice can be found at MoveUpMS.com
The Mississippi Center for Public Policy sponsored this post.
7 comments:
👎
Louisiana has a magnet school program that allows a student to go to any public school in the area as long as they qualify for the magnet program. My brother and I lived in the same house but went to two rival high schools.
https://attorneygenerallynnfitch.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/J.Harkins-October-03-2024-National-Guard-AGR.pdf-.pdf
Madison County School District is refusing to honor the intent of this law for military families. When servicemembers have inquired about allowing their kids to continue to attend Germantown or Madison Central if the family moves out of the district, Madison County Schools gave a resounding no and offered the child a spot at Velma Jackson. It's not real school choice if you can only attend the lowest performing school in the district.
@12:21... Aren't Madison Central and Germantown busting at the seams with students already? (Ridgeland maybe, too?)
Yes also include Northwest Rankin and Brandon etc.
Local news reported the bill extends to some, but not all Nat'l Guard folks.
Post a Comment