Collection of all posts about Lamar Adams case.
The SEC and Butler Snow settled for $9.5 million in the Lamar Adams case. SEC Receiver Allyson Mills submitted a motion for settlement to U.S. District Judge Carlton Reeves on January 11. The settlement agreement and motion are posted below.
The agreement states Lord Snow denies "any wrongdoing." The powerhouse Ridgeland law firm must pay the settlement within ten days of the effective date. The agreement bars any parties from suing Lord Snow for any damages arising out of the Lamar Adams case. The Receiver will dismiss all claims against the firm within ten days after payment is made in full.
Judge Reeves scheduled a hearing on the settlement motion for February 23 at 1:30 PM. Interested parties must submit comments to the Court at least five days prior to the hearing.
Synopsis of Case
The SEC is trying to claw back illegal profits earned by Lamar Adams and promoters of a $164 million Ponzi scheme based on phony timber investments. Receiver Alysson Mills represents the SEC in recovering assets for later distribution to the victims. Her efforts include suing promoters who received commissions as well as the Butler Snow and Baker Donelson law firms. Adams is incarcerated in federal prison after he pleaded guilty to one count of wire fraud.
Receiver Alysson Mills sued Butler Snow, Butler Snow Business Advisory
Division President Matt Thornton, and Baker Donelson in U.S. District
Court on December 19, 2018 to recover commissions paid to them in the
Lamar Adams timber fraud case. The complaint charges employees at both
law firms worked with Lamar Adams to sell phony timber investments to
firm clients.
The complaint states Adams and Pinnacle Trust formed the Madison Timber
Fund, LLC. It sought to raise $10 million through the sale of 100
shares at a share price of $100,000. Butler Snow lawyers worked with
Adams on the PPM. However, the PPM did not attract any investors.
Butler Snow created an Advisory Services division that would provide
“non-legal business advice” in 2011. Mike Billings joined Lord Snow in
2012 as a “strategic advisor.” Ms. Mills said Billings gave strategic
advice to Madison Timber as the company sought to raise $30-$50
million. Thornton allegedly "alerted" senior partners Don and Barry
Cannada about the new business. Adams paid BSAS $3,500 per month for 17
months. Thornton and Billings looked for clients to purchase timber
shares. They created a list of over thirty local individuals and
families as prospects. Many people on the list purchased the phony
timber shares.
The complaint stated Lord Snow lawyers created a PPM in February 2013
that sought to raise $100 million by selling $1,000 shares at a price
of $100,000 per share. Lord Snow moved up from local yokels and began
to pitch the shares to larger, institutional investors. Unfortunately
(sarcasm) for Team Thornton, the PPM fell flat but there was a
timber lining in the cloud of failure as many of the prospects
invested in “standing tracts” of timber land. Adams delivered
commission checks for each sale to Lord Snow.
The Receiver accused Butler Snow, Billings, and Thornton, of acting as
"unlicensed brokers, in violation of state and federal law." No one
ever registered with the SEC as the promissory notes were sold and
commission checks were delivered. Ms. Mills aimed her complaint
squarely at Barry Cannada:
Butler Snow knew or should have known what it was doing was unlawful. Among the notes in Butler Snow’s Madison Timber files is this comment from Don Cannada in 2009: “Very broad definition of what a broker is . . . Includes one who for a commission procures a purchaser or prospect etc. See 73-35-31 for penalties. Says you can’t pay an unlicensed broker, but doesn’t provide any penalty if you do so.”
Billings was making so much money off of the timber scheme that he left Lord Snow in December 2013 and began working directly for Lamar Adams. Adams stopped paying the $3,500 monthly retainer fee to Lord Snow. However, Adams engaged Lord Snow to assist him in other projects such as the Oxford Springs development in North Mississippi. The complaint makes it clear that Adams enjoyed the full range of Lord Snow’s diverse offerings: legal services, business advice, and lobbying. Butler Snow, in true Shylock fashion, continued to bill Adams for services rendered after he was caught. Lord Snow finally terminated the relationship on May 11 – two days after he pleaded guilty and 11 days after he was indicted.
Billings settled for $800,000.
Kingfish note: Billings must have been broke because he held a yard sale in 2020 where he sold many of his prized, worldly possessions, including some fancy slippers.
Posted below: Order setting hearing to approve settlement, motion for settlement, settlement agreement.
23 comments:
Hell, they basically got that in PPP money while working remotely. At worst, it's a wash financially for them.
"Says you can’t pay an unlicensed broker, but doesn’t provide any penalty if you do so."
Dealt with a lot of attorneys over the years. That interpretation of the lack of penalties for their commission checks is somewhat tame compared to some of the stunts I've watched a good many attorneys pull over the years. They still ridin' dirty, though.
KF has such a hard on for BS that I wouldn't be surprised if he files an objection to the settlement demanding 20 mil instead 10 mil.
Where does that leave Pinnacle Trust in this settlement?
I guess they will have to sell the corporate homes in Oxford and Destin to pay the settlement.
Pretty cheap tbh
They have 300mm plus I’m coverages
Thornton still got a job?
So, according to Mr Cannada, the statute/law "Says you can't pay an unlicensed broker"..."but doesn't provide any penalty if you do so". So, hey guys, let's go ahead and break the law since they can't penalize us. Nothing like a lawyer who advises his own firm to break the law. Geeeees. No wonder why many people don't like or trust lawyers.
I wonder if the older partners that were alive when I worked there are turning in their graves. George Butler, James O'Mara, Phineas Stevens, Bob Cannada, Hal Miller, Jr. and a few others.
James O'Mara is not deceased - it was his father, Junior O'Mara that started Butler, Snow, O'Mara, et al - FYI
4:02 pm
Said a mouthful.
Erosion of trust.
Pinnacle “Trust” needs to be investigated. I have friends who purchased timber shares at the recommendation of a representative there.
With Mississippi being a state with an economy so dependent on federal transfer payments, is there anything possible other than these get rich quick scams and made up BS public works projects to create jobs and wealth in Mississippi?
Maybe no civil monetary penalty in that statute, but what about the "CRIMINAL" penalties in other statutes. Wasn't Zach Scruggs (lawyer) indicted/convicted of "MISPRISON OF A FELONY" or some similar crime. As I understood it, the substance of the criminal charge was that he failed to report the commission of a felony by others. Wouldn't that apply to lawyers, etc., who failed to report lawyers and others who violated the statute?
@9:02 PM - yes, public works "studies" and other "studies."
@12:27: I've noticed that bias against this firm on KF's part on several occasions.
so BS committed ''no wrongdoing''? this is an absolute farce. this is akin to the piano player in the whorehouse who insists he has no idea what is going on upstairs.
what will the ms state bar association do about all this?.............nothing..........
it was his father, Junior O'Mara
Yes it was. I think he was still there during the early 70s. Jimmy was also there. His office was near Carl Black's.
Smart move by the firm. Big distraction. Best to move on.
As a client with a retainer at Butler Snow, I can tell you that amount is pocket lint that falls when they tip the bathroom attendant.
So where does this leave Baker Donelson?
No impact on Pinnacle Trust or Baker.
Post a Comment